AI Metafiction on Grief
- Idea: 1.77 of 5
- Form: 2.00 of 5
- Voice: 3.56 of 5
Overall = 2.44 out of 5
There are mixed reviews on this, so I thought I’d grade it with my framework. It’s great on some dimensions, good on others, but poor on most of them. Overall, it’s barely good. I think this shows that 1) casual readers are often impressed by a single pattern, like if it can do repetition it’s a big deal, 2) skeptics will take the absence of a single pattern to completely discredit it, and 3) even though it’s not “good” yet (an overall 3/5) it’s generally a big deal that we’re close to anyone being able to get good writing for free on-demand. Most people can’t write a 2.44.